‘The Tree’ – Movie Review

Dawn and Peter O’Neil live with their kids in rural Queensland in a ramshackle house shaded by a gigantic Moreton Bay fig tree (which took the filmmakers weeks to find, apparently…it’s really quite magnificent). Clearly, the family are not materially wealthy, but life is good. Then tragedy strikes: Peter has a fatal heart attack. The film (a French-Australian co-production) focuses on Dawn and 8-year-old daughter, Simone, as they struggle to come to terms with their loss.

Simone finds solace in the heart of the tree – a junction of trunk and branches, where she sets up a shrine to her father. She fancies she can hear him talking to her through the rustling leaves, and in time entrusts her mother with her secret. Dawn, too, comes to associate her late husband with the tree, which sends its hyper-fast-growing roots out to embrace the house, as if in response.

The tree’s benevolent mood takes a sinister turn when a relationship develops between Dawn and a local plumber: a massive branch breaks off, crashing through the roof and coming to rest across her bed! Lotsa symbolism happening here…and there’s more. Frankly, it’s all a bit laboured by the end of the movie.

Obviously, then, this film operates partly on a lyrical level, but there is a problem here – a clash, rather than a happy confluence, between poetry and realism. Continue reading ‘The Tree’ – Movie Review

‘The Reluctant Infidel’ – Movie Review


Humour’s a funny thing (heh heh – sorry). So often I sit there po-faced in comedies while the rest of the cinema crowd rolls about, overcome with hilarity.

A couple of weeks back watching The Other Guys, for example, I barely raised a smirk, yet all around young males (mostly) guffawed, stamped their feet, clapped their approval in the darkness even (never have seen the point of clapping at a movie screen, but there ya go).

Is it an age thang? Maybe, in the case of The Other Guys. But I think not. After the movie I ran into someone I know who’s a much older fart than I who laughed all the way through it. Besides, I got the jokes – I just didn’t find them funny.

Same went for The Four Lions. I thought that was real shite. Jihadist characters dumber than the Three Stooges, but not remotely funny. Stupid story. And as a satire with pretensions more serious than merely making people laugh – a miserable failure.

So, I wasn’t optimistic fronting up for The Reluctant Infidel (The Infidel in Britain…seems they figured we colonials needed some spoonfeeding). Well, you know what’s coming. Continue reading ‘The Reluctant Infidel’ – Movie Review

‘Please Give’ – Movie Review


New York’s the location for this ‘slice of life’ movie, although it could be any urban setting. There’s nothing particularly Noo Yawk about the characters, and unusually for films shot in the Big Apple, the city itself does not feature heavily.

A mistake, perhaps, for this movie needs something more than it delivers – a lot more. Slice-of-life comedy/dramas are a dime a dozen, and the problem with most of them, or at least the majority of the ones I’ve seen in recent years, is that the slices they offer, while ‘realistic’, are not very interesting. Such is the case with Please Give. Continue reading ‘Please Give’ – Movie Review

movie reviews + occasional other musings